Morning Report: Change in tax treatment for MSRs?

Vital Statistics:

  Last Change
S&P futures 4,446 -16.2
Oil (WTI) 66.42 -2.45
10 year government bond yield   1.27%
30 year fixed rate mortgage   3.07%

Stocks are lower after weaker-than-expected economic data out of China and continuing fears about COVID. Bonds and MBS are up.


In terms of economic data this week, we will get retail sales, industrial production, and housing starts. Jerome Powell will speak on Tuesday, and we will get the FOMC minutes on Wednesday.


As part of the infrastructure package, the government is looking at what is basically an Alternative Minimum Tax for corporations. It supposedly would look at increases in book value and tax that at 15% as a floor. One area that would impact mortgage originators is mortgage servicing rights. As of now, mortgage servicing rights are capitalized when created, and there is no income realized until the they are sold or fees are collected.

Under the new proposal, they would be taxed immediately, since book value increases once they are capitalized. Given the issues with potential Basel-like capital requirements for non-bank GNMA originators, MSR pricing in the secondary market will remain under pressure.


United Wholesale reported second quarter earnings this morning. Volumes increased 20% to $59 billion, however gain on sale margins were down big, more or less as expected. In the first quarter, gain on sale margins were 2.19% and they fell to 0.81% in the second quarter. FWIW, the company guided on its Q1 earnings call that margins would be down big in Q2, although Matt Ishbia also expected that to be the bottom. For the third quarter, UWM is guiding for volumes to to come in at $57-62 billion and for gain on sale margins to be in the 0.75% – 1.00% range. Note that Rocket on Friday also guided that the margin compression is probably over as well.


The big question for the mortgage market is when to begin the tapering process (or reducing the current $80 billion a month pace of MBS and Treasury purchases). The Fed wants to avoid a repeat of the 2013 “taper tantrum” where Treasury yields got away from them quickly. It sounds like it could start anywhere from September to mid-2022.

The big difference between 2013 and today is the state of the economy. In December 2013 the Fed started reducing its purchases and unemployment was 6.7%. Today, unemployment is at 5.4%. Inflation is higher as well, although much of that is due to supply chain constraints which can’t be influenced by monetary policy. Labor constraints are also an issue, and that is increasing the cost of homebuilding and the Fed is wary of the fast pace of home price appreciation. While the Fed can’t control the supply and demand imbalance in the housing market, they can influence mortgage rates. This issue will probably push up the tapering process, especially for MBS purchases. We will have to see how home prices look as we head into the seasonally slow period.

One important thing to keep in mind is that MBS spreads (that is the difference between the yield on Treasuries and MBS) were much wider during 2013, with the spread reaching something like 150 basis points. Today, spreads are closer to 70 basis points. If history repeats itself, we should see higher mortgage rates going forward if the economy continues to improve. If it does not, and Treasury yields work lower, mortgage rates will struggle to get much lower.

17 Responses

  1. This is true and does not bode well for overall competency.


  2. Absolutely exquisite!


  3. One of the COVID related tax breaks has been clawed back, retrospectively,at least in practical effect. The late written reg says that a sole proprietor owner of a sub s corp can only keep the loss of income benefit he took last year if he has no living children, parents, or siblings. It is the freaking strangest deal ever.

    And Congress may well be too busy or too giveashit to fix this.


  4. The smart play then is to fly to Juarez or Matamoros and walk across the border. Easy-peasy.


  5. Lol!


  6. Was not really expecting this from Rick Scott. Is he facing a tough primary?


  7. Joe Biden, conman?


    • Shocking. Primarily because it is indicative that at least owners and management know what will happen if their ideas for everybody else are put in place at the DailyKos–bankruptcy and dissolution. Which I always find interesting. How is they always know it’s a bad idea when it comes to them?


Be kind, show respect, and all will be right with the world.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: