August Case-Schiller came in at 142.84, down 3.8% from a year ago. Home prices are back to Summer 2003 levels. Certainly the chart gives no indication of gathering strength, if anything it looks like we have had a meager (at best) dead cat bounce off the bottom, and are now in a decling channel with lower highs and lower lows. Detroit and Washington DC were the only MSAs that were up while the worst performers were Portland, Phoenix, and Minneapolis. June and July numbers were revised down as well.
Certainly there is nothing to indicate strength in the housing market. We are going into a seasonally weak period and the consumer is in a foul mood as evidenced by the Conference Board Consumer Confidence reading of 39.8, which takes us back to late 08 / early 09 levels.
Obama’s new housing plan will probably be as successful as his earlier ones at stanching the decline in the housing market. It may help a few marginal homeowners stay in their home, but it isn’t going to do anything for troubled homeowners as they have to be current in their payments to refinance. As I discussed before, we have a demographic issue here, with the older first time buyer prematurely entering the market and the younger first time homebuyer not in a position to buy. That leaves the professionals, and they aren’t going to get interested in housing until prices are dirt cheap and we are not there yet. Against that, we have an army of baby boomers who need to downsize empty nests, or simply bought too much home and need to get out. The government is probably powerless to change this dynamic – all they can do is try and redistribute the losses.
Chart: Case-Schiller:
Filed under: Uncategorized | 23 Comments »
